19 pies that make every slice feel like a good decision

ByHeidi Bruaw

Some pies just sit on the table, and some make you feel pretty great about going back for another slice. This collection is full of the kind that hit that sweet spot—flaky crusts, rich fillings, and just the right balance of comfort and indulgence. These are the pies that make every slice feel like exactly the right call.

A slice of lemon pie with raspberries on top.
Lemon Cake Pie. Photo credit: One Hot Oven.

Cinnamon Roll Pie

A slice of cinnamon roll pie with icing on a white plate, placed on a striped cloth. Cinnamon sticks are nearby.
Cinnamon Roll Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This pie brings all the cozy goodness of a classic cinnamon roll, with soft, buttery swirls baked into every slice. It comes out rich and tender, filling the kitchen with that warm, sweet cinnamon scent. Finished with a thick layer of cream cheese frosting, every slice feels like a good decision.
Get the Recipe: Cinnamon Roll Pie

Mock Apple Pie

Slice of pie with crumb topping on a stack of plates, surrounded by crackers and cinnamon sticks.
Mock Apple Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

Mock Apple Pie captures that familiar apple-pie taste using Ritz crackers in the most surprising way. It’s one of those recipes that makes people do a double take after the first bite. Sweet, cozy, and a little nostalgic, it proves simple ingredients can work a little magic.
Get the Recipe: Mock Apple Pie

Kool-Aid Pie

A slice of creamy pie with whipped cream on top sits on stacked plates beside a whole pie, wooden spoons, orange slices, and a glass of milk on a red checkered cloth.
Kool-Aid Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This creamy Kool-Aid pie comes together with just four simple ingredients and a short chill in the fridge. It’s the kind of easy dessert you can throw together without much thought at all. Once you cut into it, don’t be surprised if the slices disappear fast.
Get the Recipe: Kool-Aid Pie

Black Bottom Pie

A slice of chocolate cream pie, reminiscent of classic black bottom pie, is topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings on a white plate. The rest of the pie sits in a glass dish on a festive tablecloth with holiday designs.
Black Bottom Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

Meet Black Bottom Pie, a classic dessert with a deep chocolate layer, a smooth custard kissed with a hint of liqueur, and a generous pile of fluffy whipped cream on top. Every slice feels a little special with its mix of creamy and rich textures. It’s the kind of treat that brings back the sweetest memories with every bite.
Get the Recipe: Black Bottom Pie

Key Lime Pie

A key lime pie topped with whipped cream and lime slices sits on a wooden board. A slice has been cut and a pie server rests nearby, with crumbs and lime wedges scattered around.
Key Lime Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This key lime pie comes out smooth, creamy, and packed with bright citrus flavor in every bite. The silky filling pairs perfectly with a buttery graham cracker crust that makes every slice feel like a good decision. It’s easy to make, but once it’s on the table, it won’t stick around for long.
Get the Recipe: Key Lime Pie

Apple Pie

A slice of crumb-topped pie on a white decorative plate with a fork next to it. A red and white cloth is partially visible in the corner.
Apple Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This apple pie is made with everyday pantry staples and finished with a playful twist on top. The crust comes together easily, while a crumbly corn flake topping adds a satisfying crunch. Each slice is filled with soft apples and cozy spices that make every bite feel just right.
Get the Recipe: Apple Pie

Costco Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

A slice of layered chocolate and peanut butter pie on a white plate with a wooden spoon, placed on a red and white checkered napkin.
Costco Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This Costco-inspired chocolate peanut butter pie doesn’t stick around for long once it’s served. It starts with a buttery graham cracker crust, piled high with a light, creamy peanut butter filling and finished with a thick layer of rich chocolate. Once people get a slice, it tends to disappear quicker than you’d expect.
Get the Recipe: Costco Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Chocolate Macaroon Pie

A slice of chocolate coconut pie sits on a white decorative plate, with the rest of the pie in a glass dish nearby. Perfect for thanksgiving pies, it features a toasted coconut topping atop a red and white checkered tablecloth.
Chocolate Macaroon Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

Chocolate Macaroon Pie starts with a deep, chocolatey crust and fills it with a soft, gooey coconut center that tastes just like a giant macaroon. Each slice is rich, sweet, and loaded with that classic chocolate-coconut combo. It’s the kind of dessert that makes portion control feel completely optional.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Macaroon Pie

Lemon Cake Pie

A slice of lemon pie with raspberries on top.
Lemon Cake Pie. Photo credit: One Hot Oven.

This Lemon Cake Pie blends the soft, tender feel of cake with the creamy richness of pie in one easy dessert. The bright lemon flavor adds a fresh, citrusy kick that keeps each bite light and inviting. Every slice feels like a good decision, especially when you’re craving something sweet with a little zing.
Get the Recipe: Lemon Cake Pie

Grasshopper Pie

A slice of mint Oreo dessert, reminiscent of grasshopper pie with its green creamy filling and crushed Oreo topping, sits on a white plate with a fork. In the background, a small jar filled with Oreos rests on a yellow surface.
Grasshopper Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

No-Bake Grasshopper Pie is cool, creamy, and packed with refreshing mint flavor in every bite. The crunchy Oreo crust gives the smooth filling the perfect bit of contrast. A splash of crème de menthe brings that classic, nostalgic flavor that makes this pie so hard to resist.
Get the Recipe: Grasshopper Pie

Strawberry Cream Pie

Strawberry cream pie in clear pie dish with bowl of strawberries in background.
Strawberry Cream Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This Strawberry Cream Pie is the kind of refreshing dessert you can enjoy any time of year. It starts with a crunchy Corn Flake crust and is finished with a smooth, creamy filling that balances everything out. Each slice is light, sweet, and feels like just the right choice when you want something easy that still feels a little special.
Get the Recipe: Strawberry Cream Pie

Old Fashioned Coconut Cream PIe

A slice of Old Fashioned Coconut Cream Pie with whipped topping sits on a white decorative plate, placed on a pink striped cloth next to a peach-colored flower.
Old Fashioned Coconut Cream PIe. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

Coconut Cream Pie is smooth, creamy, and packed with rich coconut flavor in every bite. Each slice has that old-fashioned charm that brings to mind classic desserts shared around the table. It’s a simple, comforting treat that never goes out of style.
Get the Recipe: Old Fashioned Coconut Cream PIe

Peanut Butter Pie

A slice of peanut butter pie topped with whipped cream and peanuts, on a white plate with the whole pie in the background.
Peanut Butter Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This peanut butter pie is smooth, creamy, and hard to walk away from. The light, rich filling rests on a crisp graham cracker crust, giving you that perfect mix of fluffy and crunchy in every bite. After the first slice, it’s pretty easy to forget about stopping at just one.
Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Pie

Victory Blueberry Pie

A slice of blueberry pie with a golden crust and visible berry filling sits on a white plate; additional pie slices are in the background.
Victory Blueberry Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

Classic blueberry pie is one of those desserts that disappears fast once it hits the table. Sweet, juicy blueberries bake down into a thick, bubbling filling inside a buttery, flaky crust. Don’t expect many slices to be left behind once everyone grabs a piece.
Get the Recipe: Victory Blueberry Pie

S’mores Pie

A close-up of a S'mores Pie in a foil pan, topped with toasted marshmallows—some golden brown, others deeply roasted—on a wooden surface with a plain white background.
S’mores Pie. Photo credit: Real Life of Lulu.

This no-bake S’mores Pie brings all those classic campfire flavors into one cool, creamy dessert. Rich chocolate, fluffy marshmallow, and a buttery graham cracker base layer together in every bite. Every forkful feels like a little trip back to those sweet, familiar moments.
Get the Recipe: S’mores Pie

Blackberry Crumble Pie

Overhead shot of blackberry crumble pie with one slice on a serving plate.
Blackberry Crumble Pie. Photo credit: Renee Nicole’s Kitchen.

This blackberry crumble pie starts with a sweet, homemade berry filling layered over a buttery crust. A spiced crumb topping bakes up golden and adds the perfect crunch on top. It’s rich, cozy, and hard to stop at just one slice.
Get the Recipe: Blackberry Crumble Pie

Million Dollar Pie

A cream pie topped with whipped cream, red cherries, and chopped nuts in a foil pie tin.
Million Dollar Pie. Photo credit: xoxoBella.

Million Dollar Pie comes together quickly and brings plenty of sweet, creamy flavor to the table. It’s a no-bake dessert that keeps things simple without sacrificing taste. One slice in, and it’s easy to see why it’s such a favorite.
Get the Recipe: Million Dollar Pie

Triple Berry Hand Pies

Closeup of a broken open triple berry hand pie.
Triple Berry Hand Pies. Photo credit: All Ways Delicious.

Triple Berry Hand Pies are a great way to make the most of fresh, ripe berries. Each one is wrapped in a flaky, buttery crust that bakes up golden and tender. The sweet, juicy filling is packed with berry flavor in every bite.
Get the Recipe: Triple Berry Hand Pies

Sugar Cream Pie

A slice of sugar cream pie on a white and floral plate.
Sugar Cream Pie. Photo credit: One Hot Oven.

I’m so excited to pass along this Classic Sugar Cream Pie recipe. It’s rich, silky, and every bite feels a little indulgent. It’s one of those desserts that’s simple but still feels special. And if you know, you know—it’s a true Hoosier favorite!
Get the Recipe: Sugar Cream Pie