11 Ingredients that Elevate Box Cake Mix to Bakery Worthy

Convenience is the main reason for using boxed cake mixes, even though many bakers argue that the taste and texture of a cake made from a mix often don’t have the depth of flavor and quality you get with traditional baking methods. That’s where cake mix baking hacks come into play. Read on for 11 ingredients that, when added to box cake mix, elevate the end result to something bakery worthy.

A mixing bowl with yellow batter is being poured into a rectangular baking dish on a black stovetop. A white spatula is used to help transfer the batter.
Photo credit: Leah Ingram.

Whole Milk

A glass pitcher filled with milk next to a clear glass also containing milk. Both are set against a white background.
Photo credit: Depositphotos.

Using milk instead of water adds flavor and moisture to the cake. If you use whole milk, that will provide extra fat for richness and a denser texture for the cake that you eventually bake.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Coconut Milk

three brands of coconut milk horizontal
Photo credit: Leah Ingram.

By swapping coconut milk for cow’s milk, you can make a vegan cake without any animal products. Coconut milk is most commonly used as a cream replacement in dairy-free baking, as it results in a creamy texture for just about everything.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Extra Eggs

A white bowl with two cracked eggs next to a whisk, an egg carton with whole eggs, and a bowl with eggshells on a wooden surface.
Photo credit: Adobe Photos.

Eggs add richness, moisture and structure to a cake. You can opt to add just an extra egg yolk, and for white cakes, use just the egg whites. Or, if you’re baking a vegan cake, you can use an extra serving of egg substitute.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Melted Butter

softening butter
Photo credit: Adobe Photos.

Use melted butter instead of oil and double the amount when mixing a boxed cake mix. The melted butter will add a richness that cooking oil simply cannot.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Sour Cream

A wooden spoon scooping creamy white yogurt from a brown bowl placed on a woven mat with a brown cloth in the background.
Photo credit: Depositphotos.

Not unlike whole milk, adding sour cream to box cake mix gives it more fat, which enhances the flavor. However, unlike milk, which can make the batter thin and runny, sour cream will keep the batter thick and moist.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Greek Yogurt

A hand is holding a container of yogurt in front of an open refrigerator filled with various items. The nutritional facts label on the yogurt container is visible.
Photo credit: Leah Ingram.

Using Greek yogurt in a cake mix is a lot like using sour cream. You’re going for a thicker, creamier texture without making the batter runny. With Greek yogurt, you can use a plain flavored, vanilla or another flavor that you like. Go with full-fat Greek yogurt for the best flavor.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Vanilla Extract

A glass bottle labeled "Vanilla extract" is placed next to a few vanilla beans on a wooden surface.
Photo credit: Depositphotos.

Enhance your cake’s flavor by adding pure vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste to level up the flavor of your cake without adding many extra ingredients.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Spices

A plastic container labeled "Kirkland Ground Saigon Cinnamon" with a volume of 10.7 oz (303g) and featuring a black flip-top lid.
Photo credit: Leah Ingram.

Add an aromatic touch with a generous sprinkle of spices. Options like warm and comforting cinnamon, fragrant cardamom or earthy nutmeg are simple to add to the cake batter. Try adding ground or fresh ginger to the batter.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Maple Syrup

A glass bottle shaped like a maple leaf filled with amber liquid, featuring a green label that reads "Real Maine." The bottle is placed on a rock surrounded by autumn leaves.
Photo credit: Maine Maple Producers Association.

Maple syrup can give it a, well, maple-y flavor. It is one of the main ingredients used in this recipe for Cake Mix Maple Pecan Cupcakes.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Fruits

A bowl of fresh, vibrant red strawberries, some sliced and some whole, arranged in a decorative bowl with red and blue patterns.
Photo credit: Leah Ingram.

Fruits like strawberries, apples, blueberries, coconut and citrus add bursts of natural sweetness and delicious flavors. Plus, they can turn your cake batter into interesting colors naturally versus adding artificial colors from dyes or sprinkles.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Vegetables

A metal mixing bowl filled with whipped, creamy orange mixture and a metal whisk attachment inside. The bowl is placed on a gray surface.
Photo credit: Bagels and Lasagna.

Mixed in shredded vegetables to take your cake to a whole other layer, such as a carrot cake or a chocolate zucchini cake. Or add pumpkin puree to make a cake with a fall flavor.
Read the article: How to Make Box Cake Mix Better

Similar Posts